The Relevance Of Ethics And Reputation In Business…..The Maduka And Uba Tangle By Charles Ololo

By Charles Ololo

There is a huge connection between business ethics and reputation. Ethical business behaviour, such as trust, helps build reputation overtime. While public relations is good, it is not a substitute for business reputation earned through good product or many years of providing excellent service, and excellent relationships with customers, suppliers,  bankers etc.

Ethics and reputation are intangible aspects and assets of every business. You either have it or you do not.  Though it is intangible, the consequences depending on which side of the coin a business operates, determines whether it is a sustainable business or a flash in history. Many businesses, recognising the long term implications of reputation built overtime, emphasise ethical behaviour. Of course, undoubtedly, no pillar of unethical behaviour is worse than deception and fraud.

So, for many business analysts  and people, the recent revelation of the  business deal between Cosmas Maduka of Coscharis and Ifeanyi Uba of Capital Oil has once again brought to fore the importance and relevance of ethics and reputation in business. It is more disturbing from a general business climate perspective because many foreigners who may have seen the shame on television and You tube might believe all our businessmen cannot be trusted. But the publicity is also helpful because the underlying arguments and lessons drawn from them will have enormous ramifications on how the majority of businesses are conducted in this country going forward.

Viewed against history and from a public relations perspective, the interview granted by Ifeanyi Uba on this controversy is very disappointing and exposes him to ridicule, as many  now view his interview as classic evasiveness, providing support to the saying that “talk is cheap.” Uba failed miserably to recognise that he was fighting for the future of his business. Uba is a CEO of Capital Oil and Gas, a business he started in 2001 but did not commence business until 2007. Within five years, Capital Oil has become a major player in the downstream oil sector on the back of government licences, guaranteed demand and subsidy support. The PMS import licensing system has gifted Uba millions without any serious thinking or innovation, and Capital Oil can simply and crudely be regarded as a rent extracting company, but its an achievement all the same. However since 2009 no matter what has been fed to the public, the business has been on its knees, first crippled by the dramatic fall in oil prices during 2008 and 2009 and dealing with debts in 2010 and 2011 and now charged with over invoicing by the government in relation to subsidy in 2012.

Faced with this situation, the last thing Uba needs is  a fight with Cosmas Maduka, a man with a higher moral authority than him, with Uba failing to recognise the challenge when he went on a media round. The challenge was for Uba to prove to Nigerians and perhaps other business associates outside this country that its huge success within a short period of time is not due to deception, collusion and outright fraud. He failed to seize the moment, instead engaging in prevarications.

Some have suggested that Dr. Maduka was way too naïve to do business with Ifeanyi Uba. With hindsight, that is now the case, with a bill of N21 billion to prove. However, a common behaviour amongst matured businessmen is that they begin to invest in others as they migrate from being businessmen to being investors. And someone with Maduka's nature, having succeeded growing his businesses despite ups and downs, might feel obliged to assist someone in such circumstances as Uba.

Suffering from a collapse of his business after Banks’ foreclosure, Ifeanyi Uba persuaded Maduka he could still build a profitable business if he gets another lifeline. They agreed to import 10 vessels of PMS between May 2011 and October 2011. Maduka provided the financing while Uba provided the logistics – since he owns the licence from the Petroleum Products Pricing Regulatory Agency (PPPRA) and the Department for Petroleum Resources (DPR) and the storage facilities. Capital Oil would sell the products and use its proceeds to offset the loan collected from the bank. He mitigated all identified risks by opening letters of credit, dedication of tank, arranging verification of product delivery and subsequent sales. Maduka claims only 6 of the total financed 10 vessels were delivered whilst the whereabouts of the 4 and the product still remain a mystery thereby in consequence the bank loan remains unsettled.

These are damning allegations especially because, by providing guarantee of payment in the letters of credit, the only possibilities are that the vessels were not delivered by the sellers or they were diverted by the shipping firm. In which way, their innocence in this matter can only be derived through collusion with Uba who should receive the consignments here. So given the opportunity to answer questions on national television, it is disappointing that Uba did not give a good defence of himself on these grave allegations rather resulted to name calling.

So, in the midst of all the back and forth arguments, there are simple questions Ifeanyi Uba and Capital Oil have not answered. Was there a transaction such as this? How many ships were delivered? If the subsidy payments are the problem, are all the receipts from the petrol sold already in the bank? How were 10 letters of credit utilised and only six ships were delivered? These are the very simple questions for Uba but rather than answers all we get are statements that seek to evade any form of accountability but  blame to  everyone else for his predicament except himself. I can hope he realises this as quickly as possible to allow him protect the future of his business.

Charles Ololo writes from Lagos

 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of SaharaReporters

Comments
8 comment(s)
Post a comment

ubah's fauseful speech

ifeanyi ubah stated some huge billions of naira or there about doesn't scare anybody in capital oil.. that's shows how far his has gone in his dubious way of oil business line... i really cant find any atom of truth in his speech during his interview...

INDEED UBAH IS A FRAUDSTER IN DEPTH

indeed,there is a lot of investigation work needed to be done,though in a short while.Strictly because ubah has refused to give answers to the very simple questions,rather all what he said are statement that seeks to evade any form of accountability,but blame to everyone else for his predicament except himself.

Maduka and ubah

ubah is simply a fraudster, he was suppose to be sincere to maduka. who think he's not what people say he is, by keeping to his words.

Ifeanyi Uba must be brought to Justice

Every business or every job done with a stated agreement has to be reconciled or accounted for. Let Ubah meet with the demands of Cosmos Maduka by reconciling properly the activities of the last consignments.

Ubah is simply a successful bad manager

Without doubts, i listened to Maduka press statement. The man has got excellent relationships with multinational business organization ie the well known Coscharis, Range Rover etc. I believe that when it comes to business ethics, that is a man to look up to. Top personalities with likes Ifeanyi Ubah are people who seek to reap from other peoples ideas and influence with little no contribution from his own path.

MR UBAH A FRAUDSTER AT LARGE

the chairman of capital oil ifeanyi ubah is just acting like a little kid that fell from a bike and starts blaming the Peder and the chains for making him fall relishing the fact that it was the same set he rode on before crashing.how on earth will you just try to cry to the public on a business transaction that took place on the based on trust between himself and his fellow kinsman...he should just try to save some energy for tears latter because this is just the beginning of a catastrophe yet to unfold...

MR UBAH A FRAUDSTER AT LARGE

The chairman of capital oil Ifeanyi Ubah,is just acting like a little kid that fell from a bike and starts blaming the Peder and the chains for making him fall relishing the fact that it was the same set of machine he rode on before crashing.how on earth will you just try to cry to the public on a business transaction that took place in private based on trust between himself and his fellow kinsman...he should just try to save some energy for tears latter because this is just the beginning of a catastrophe yet to unfold...

Ethics?

Not passing judgement but Maduka is sounding more reasonable and sincere in the business partnership gone awry. Lack of scruples has bedevilled private and public sectors. Business leaders cheat to become mega billionaires and political leaders steal public funds to no end. And we celebrate and hold them in awe. Corruption is found everywhere in the whole world but it is in Africa especially in Nigeria they are never punished. Such blessings!!